| November 17, 2026
Introduction
Christians live alongside people of other faiths in many parts of the Majority World, often as a religious minority within societies shaped by other religious traditions. What does faithful Christian witness look like when most of one’s friends, colleagues, and neighbors belong to the religious majority? This question is particularly significant in Pakistan, where Christians live alongside people of other faiths and must consider how to bear witness to Jesus Christ with faithfulness, humility, and love.
The Gospel mandate is clear: Christians are called to go to all nations, to share the good news, and to make disciples (Matt. 28:19-20). However, Christian witness among other faith communities is often challenging because it requires sustained engagement with diverse religious traditions and cultural contexts, particularly in complex restrictive environments. From a South Asian perspective, Pervaiz Sultan acknowledges that sharing the Christian faith is challenging where Christians face social and religious restrictions. Nevertheless, he argues that Christians are called to maintain gospel witness by demonstrating the love of Jesus Christ through serving their neighbors.1 Furthermore, rising religious intolerance presents additional challenges for Christian engagement with people of other faiths. Despite these difficulties, Christians should build respectful relationships with their religious neighbors, embody Christ’s love through practical service, and bear faithful witness to the gospel. Over the years, various approaches and methods have been proposed to support effective Christian mission among people of different faiths.
This article examines Kosuke Koyama’s missiological insights and argues that his cruciform and neighbor-centered missiology can help Pakistani Christians hold together faithful gospel witness, contextual attentiveness, humility, and genuine love for their religious neighbors. However, Koyama’s thoughts will be appropriated critically rather than unreservedly. We can appreciate his critique of triumphalistic approaches to mission, while still evaluating his theology of religions in light of Scripture and the uniqueness of Jesus Christ.
Missiological Insights from Kosuke Koyama
Kosuke Koyama (1929-2009) was a Japanese theologian and missiologist whose work became highly influential in Asian contextual theology. In August 1960, the United Church of Japan sent him to Thailand as a missionary, where he served for eight years.2 While serving in Thailand, he devoted considerable time to learning the Thai language and understanding the local culture. He regarded this process as essential for his missionary and theological development, prioritizing learning from ordinary people, particularly farmers in northern Thailand, rather than relying primarily on the insights of prominent theologians in Christian tradition.3 For Koyama, contextual theology is a “theology from below” that begins with the needs and lived experience of ordinary people.4 He published several significant works, including Water Buffalo Theology (1974), Three Mile an Hour God (1980), No Handle on the Cross (1977), and Mount Fuji and Mount Sinai (1984).5 Drawing primarily on Water Buffalo Theology and Three Mile an Hour God, this article examines three key aspects of Koyama’s missiology: (1) mission and the crucified mind, (2) mission and the love of God, and (3) mission and Neighborology. It concludes by considering the relevance of Koyama’s missiology for Christian witness in Pakistan.
Mission and the Crucified Mind
Koyama’s concept of the “crucified mind” is grounded in self-emptying, servanthood, and the death of Christ on the cross as described in Philippians 2:5-8.6 For Koyama, the “crucified mind” shapes Christian mission through self-giving love rather than dominion, listening rather than presumption, and serving rather than conquest. This understanding informed his development of a missiology rooted in Scripture, characterized by humility, and deeply attentive to the needs of the Asian context.
Koyama contrasts the “crucified mind” with the “crusading mind.” He critiques the imperialistic and ethnocentric tendencies that historically pervaded modern Western missions, which conflated Christianization with Westernization and fostered a “crusading mind” that imposed Western cultural values on the Majority World.7 In these forms of Western missions that Koyama critiques, some missionaries viewed Asian communities as culturally inferior, reflecting ethnocentric assumptions and a limited appreciation for the local cultures and contexts. Consequently, evangelization could become entangled with Western cultural assumptions, making Christianity difficult to distinguish from Westernization.
In contrast, Koyama grounds his understanding of missions in the “crucified mind,” which calls for an approach characterized by humility, self-sacrifice, love for the local people, and respectful attentiveness to their cultural context, all guided by biblical discernment.8 Furthermore, for Koyama, Jesus’ teachings in the Gospel accounts are foundational, and he highlights two key aspects as essential to developing the missionary concept of a “crucified mind.” First, Jesus’ invitation to his disciples to follow him with total submission and humility (Matt. 16:24-25). Second, Jesus sends his disciples to fulfill the Great Commission by making disciples of all nations (Matt. 28:19-20). Koyama stresses that the “crucified mind,” characterized by humility, love, and self-sacrifice, is central to Christian witness and disciplemaking among people of other faiths and cultural contexts.9
Mission and the Love of God
Scripture teaches that every human being is created in the image of God (Gen.1:26-27). Consequently, every person possesses God-given dignity and should be treated as a neighbor worthy of love and respect. God’s creation of humanity in his image also reflects his love and care for all people. However, the fall of humanity into sin brought alienation between God and humanity (Gen. 3:1-19). Despite this brokenness, God has continually manifested his love for humanity in many ways throughout redemptive history, culminating in the saving work of Jesus Christ. Reflecting on the nature of God’s love, Koyama emphasizes that God’s ways of acting are characterized by patience and love rather than human expectation of speed and efficiency. He notes:
God walks ‘slowly’ because he is love. If he is not love he would have gone much faster. Love has its speed. It is an inner speed. It is a spiritual speed. It is a different kind of speed from the technological speed to which we are accustomed. It is ‘slow’ yet it is lord over all other speeds since it is the speed of love. It goes on in the depth of our life, whether we notice or not, whether we are currently hit by storm or not, at three miles an hour. It is the speed we walk and therefore it is the speed the love of God walks.10
For Koyama, God’s love is expressed in his patient and persistent engagement with humanity. This understanding of God’s love is reflected in Koyama’s missiology in several important ways, as discussed below:
First, God as the One Who Connects Peoples and Cultures. Koyama observes that God called Abraham from Ur of the Chaldeans and promised to give him and his descendants the Promised Land (Gen. 12:1-3). This land is situated at the crossroads of three continents and is not an isolated territory; rather, it is surrounded by different peoples, cultures, and regional powers. During their time in the land, Abraham and his descendants experienced hardships, including famine, which sometimes led them to seek refuge or assistance in Egypt. This indicates that living in the Promised Land did not guarantee an easy life, but rather a life of trust in God and a continuous experience of connecting with culturally different people from surrounding areas.11 However, these geographical and historical circumstances also carried missional significance. God called Abraham so that through him all nations might be blessed (Gen. 12:3). Abraham’s encounter with surrounding peoples and cultures can therefore be understood within the broader framework of God’s mission to extend his blessing to all nations.
Second, God as the One Who Shows No Partiality. The biblical witness testifies that God revealed himself to Israel in a unique way and established his covenant with them. Koyama observes that although Israel was chosen by God, its election was not based on its superiority or merit (Deut. 7:6-8).12 Israel was sometimes tempted to turn its privileged status into a sense of superiority over other nations. Christians can likewise be tempted to turn the gift of grace into a posture of superiority towards others.13 However, Koyama argues that such an understanding overlooks Paul’s teachings that God shows no partiality and judges both Jews and Gentiles impartially (Rom. 2:9-11).14 For Koyama, divine impartiality is closely related to Paul’s teaching of justification through faith in Jesus Christ. God’s impartiality does not contradict justification through faith in Christ; rather, it underscores that the same saving righteousness is needed by and offered to both Jews and Gentiles (Rom. 3:21-22).15
In this regard, Koyama observes that Christians have traditionally focused on Romans 3:21-22, which speaks of God’s righteousness revealed in Jesus Christ and received through faith. While affirming the centrality of this passage to the gospel, Koyama emphasizes the importance of considering Paul’s teaching on God’s impartiality in Romans 2:9-11.16 This broader reading brings an additional dimension to understanding the gospel, reminding Christians that God’s saving righteousness is not restricted to any particular ethnic or religious group.
Third, God as the God of All Nations, Including People of Other Faiths. In the study of religion, it is not uncommon for the adherents of a particular religious tradition to regard their faith as superior to others. Koyama raises an important concern about the ways in which some Christians understand and express the uniqueness and finality of Christian faith in relation to other religions.17 He emphasizes that people of other faiths are also created in the image of God and should be loved as neighbors, towards whom Christians are called to bear faithful witness to Jesus Christ. Koyama argues that theological evaluation of other religions is important; Christian mission engages real people in their lived realities, rather than just religious systems.18 He stresses that our neighbors of other faiths have their own histories, hopes, sorrows, and struggles, which cannot be understood merely through textbook descriptions of their religions.19 Faithful Christian witness does not require fear and hostility towards people of other faiths, because our confidence rests in Jesus Christ. Instead, Christians are called to engage their neighbours with love, humility and respect while remaining faithful to the gospel. Jesus Christ’s suffering and crucifixion reveal God’s profound love for humanity and provide the foundation for Christian engagement with people of other nations.20
Koyama rightly emphasizes that Christians should engage with people of other faiths as fellow human beings, treating them with love and respect rather than merely viewing them as representatives of a particular religious system. Nevertheless, such an approach does not require Christians to compromise their commitment to the uniqueness of Christ, through whom reconciliation with God is made possible. Christian witness should hold together loving engagement with people of other religions and faithfulness to the gospel.
Mission and Neighborology
One challenge of modern missions is the tendency to adopt an overly programmatic approach, which may not adequately account for the different contexts in which it takes place. As a result, people may be treated as evangelistic targets rather than real individuals and neighbors with unique experiences, beliefs, and needs.21
Koyama’s concept of Neighborology emphasizes encountering people of other faiths as neighbors rather than objects of mission, recognizing their God-given dignity and the call to engage with them with humility, love, and respect.22 To illustrate his point, Koyama reflects on meeting a woman in Thailand with whom he wished to share the gospel. His account highlights how an imperialist, one-sided approach to mission can prevent a genuine encounter with others. By focusing on his missionary agenda, he risked treating the woman as an object of evangelism rather than a person with her own experience and insights.23 Koyama’s reflection suggests that genuine encounters require missionaries not only to share the gospel but also to listen attentively to the experiences and stories of the people they serve. Thus, for Koyama, Neighborology means that before asking, “How can I convert this person?” Christians learn to ask, “Who is this neighbor before me, what is their story, and how can I love and truthfully witness to Christ in this actual relationship?” This understanding reshapes Christian mission and engagement with people of other faiths.
Koyama emphasizes the importance of exegeting both Scripture and the cultural contexts of our neighbors to communicate the gospel meaningfully.24 Missionaries must therefore interpret the Bible faithfully while listening carefully to and understanding the culture and experiences of those they encounter. Although cultural understanding informs contextualization, it remains accountable to the authority of Scripture. This approach enables Christians to bear faithful witness to Christ in ways that speak meaningfully to real people in their particular context. Another key aspect of this is learning from Christ’s example. The Gospels portray Jesus as welcoming and kind, listening to and teaching people across social and religious boundaries (Mark 10:13–16; Luke 7:36–50; Luke 13:11-16; John 4:7–26). He engaged with them personally, showing compassion and treating them with dignity rather than allowing social barriers to prevent meaningful relationships. In the Asian context, highly technical theological language can create unnecessary barriers when it is disconnected from people’s culture, context, and lived experience. People can better understand the gospel when it is communicated in language and forms that connect with their everyday lives. Christians may struggle to build meaningful relationships when they approach others as cultural outsiders who presume superiority or fail to respect local cultures. Following Koyama’s emphasis on neighborology, missionaries are encouraged to enter relationships as guests, learners, and neighbors, listening with humility and respecting the dignity of others even as they bear faithful and intelligible witness to Christ without compromising the gospel.
The Relevance of Kosuke Koyama’s Missiology in the Pakistani Context
In Pakistan, Christians live alongside neighbors of other faiths in everyday settings such as the neighborhood, workplace, schools, and local marketplaces. These relationships become especially significant when communities face shared challenges of poverty, natural disasters, illness, and other social crises, creating opportunities for mutual care and service. In this context, Koyama’s concepts of the “crucified mind” and Neighborology encourage Christians to approach their neighbors with humility, attentive listening, and the demonstration of Christ’s love through practical service. Koyama’s missiological insights are relevant to the Pakistani context in the following ways:
First, Koyama’s concept of the “crucified mind” calls Christians to approach their neighbors with humility, self-sacrificial love, and respect for their God-given dignity. Although Christians are a religious minority in Pakistan, their contribution to healthcare, education, and humanitarian assistance demonstrates how Koyama’s missiological vision can be embodied through practical service. By serving across religious boundaries, Christians express solidarity and compassion during illness, bereavement, floods, and other crises. Such service reflects genuine neighbor-love rather than merely functioning as a strategy for evangelism. It embodies Christlike love through practical expression of care and solidarity.
Second, Koyama’s concept of Neighborology emphasizes communicating Christ relationally and intelligibly through genuine human relationships. He does not separate theology from relationships; rather, he calls for theological reflection and for Christians to proceed at the “walking speed” of actual relationships, just as Christ became incarnate, walking “three miles an hour” (the average speed of a human being), to demonstrate his love. In Pakistan, this approach encourages Christians to build trust with their neighbors through everyday conversations, hospitality, and shared experiences. It also challenges them to communicate the gospel in language and ways that connect with people’s lived realities. Such an approach allows Christian witness to emerge naturally through relationships without reducing neighbors to targets of evangelism.
Third, Koyama’s call to exegete both Scripture and the local culture offers an important framework for Christian witness in Pakistan, where theological dialogue on topics of mutual interest provides an important opportunity to bear witness to the gospel. Rather than approaching interactions with an attitude of superiority and hostility, Christians can develop an informed understanding of the religious traditions, beliefs, and practices of the communities among whom they live and serve. This requires more than politeness or friendliness: it calls for costly self-denial, patient listening, and the wisdom and courage to speak the truth about Christ without dominating every conversation. Through sustained love, humble witness, and genuine relationships across religious differences, Christians can embody Christlike character while remaining faithful to the gospel.
Conclusion
Kosuke Koyama offers a compelling framework for Christian mission among people of other faiths. His critique of a crusading or bulldozing mindset challenges Christians everywhere to embrace a mission shaped by Christ’s self-giving love. For the church in Pakistan, this vision invites a distinctive missionary witness marked not by fear, defensiveness, or conquest, but by cruciform confidence, deep listening, truthful proclamation, and sustained neighbor-love. Ultimately, Christians are called to this way of mission because Jesus Christ first came among us in self-giving love. Following him means serving our neighbors with humility, courage, and faithfulness while remaining committed to the gospel.
Noman Shahbaz is a PhD student in Theological Studies at the International Graduate School of Leadership–Asia Graduate School of Theology (IGSL–AGST), Philippines. He also serves as a short-term international faculty member at IGSL. His ministry experience includes serving with the Assemblies of God Church and Langham Preaching Seminars in Karachi, Pakistan. Noman is married to Shazia, and they have two daughters, Shekinah and Shazweet.